Constance: A Story of Early Plymouth


Constance, what best could be described as historical romance for the middle-grade or young adult market, is a fabulous book about the hardships and times of early Colonial America. Here, we follow Constance Hopkins (a real passenger on the Mayflower) on her journey to the unknown New World. She has fears like everyone else of the unknown but she not only overcomes them but she thrives.

As one of the few girls/women to survive the first hard winter of Plymouth, MA, (where half the passengers died), she is very popular amongst the boys/men for a wife. She herself is unsure of what even love is. John Cooke is the first passenger to express an interest but she never really has one in him. She flirts with two men who are her father’s indentured servants who end up in a quarrel over her. But her heart doesn’t truly begin to feel until the arrival of the Fortune, the second ship to Plymouth, bringing a red-headed, strong-willed, nineteen-year-old Stephen Deane to shore. He stays with the Hopkins family for a spell while houses are being built and Constance likes him but is unsure–he is a flirt.

The next ship, the Anne, brings a one Nicholas Snow whom she quarrels with right off the bat. Yet he intrigues her. Soon, both men become serious in her and begin courting her. Stephen is the first to ask for her hand and she accepts. She thinks she is happy but is unsure. Both men depart on a hunting expedition for two weeks, which is accompanied by powerful storms. Only then does she realize she loves Nicholas.

In the end, he confesses his love for her and vice-versa and all live happily ever after.

Good quotes from the book I liked:

P. 102 “I am beginning to learn that the things one fears rarely come to pass.”

P. 158 “Any man who owes money to another is a slave!” This references the debt the colonists owed their sponsors of the voyage.

P. 218 “There is much to be done in this new world, and a man and a wife working together are the best people to do it.” I liked this for its truth today as much as yesterday.

Written in 1968 by Patricia Clapp, this novel has withstood the test of time as it remains every bit the classic today as it was then.

This book goes beyond just the original passengers on the Mayflower and one begins to understand how the settlement and the population grew as we learn more and more ships arrived, bringing more and more colonists.  So often we just read about the first winter and the first Thanksgiving and it seems history stops there; but it doesn’t.  There is so much more to the growth of the original colonies and this book does an excellent job of showing that growth.  One truly begins to see how the Native Americans were pushed back and overwhelmed by the sheer numbers of immigrants arriving from the Old World.

Good historical accuracy. Great tidbits thrown in of the hardships and the sickness one had to endure. Great survival story and a story of thriving. Good emphasis on God and how important He was to the Pilgrims. Good portrayalship of the Native Americans. An overall good read and our favorite of the summer. Recommended for ages 10 and up but my son enjoyed the story as well and he’s six.

One thought on “Constance: A Story of Early Plymouth

  1. I will check this book out. I am a member of the Mayflower Society in the state of Washington. My pilgrim is Mary Chilton, James and Susanna Chilton.

Leave a Reply